Request Consultation

Blog / Business Law

Business Dispute: San Diego Comic Con Sues Salt Lake City Comic Con

Two men shaking hands across a conference table, smiling.

San Diego Comic Con, that most famous of comic book and sci-fi conventions, is in a legal battle with neighboring Salt Lake Comic Con. The suit is one of copyright infringement, as San Diego is alleging Salt Lake has capitalized on its intellectual property to enhance its own convention. The heart of the issue come down to the similarity in names, which San Diego alleges can be confusing to convention-goers. While other cities in the United States have similar conventions and call them Comic Cons, the similar sounding names of San Diego and Salt Lake were enough for San Diego to single out Utah's capitol city for suing.

Salt Lake City Comic Con Hires Attorney to Represent them in Business Dispute

Salt Lake is having none of it. In fact, Salt Lake has hired a lawyer from San Diego's own state of California to represent them. The organizers of the Salt Lake convention have hired Sterling Brennan, an Orange County, California attorney to defend them against San Diego's assertions that the two convention names are similar enough to cause a trademark violation. San Diego also alleges people may think the two conventions are associated with each other due to the similar names. Brennan is tasked with defending Salt Lake against these allegations and obtaining a court ruling that will allow them to retain their convention name.

Brennan and those who work for him are known to be among the best intellectual property lawyers in the country. Hiring him shows that Salt Lake means business when it comes to keeping its name. In business to business disputes like this, particularly intellectual property and trademark violation lawsuits, the legal waters can often be murky. The choice of Brennan as the attorney for the case ensures Salt Lake of getting a fair trial against the larger, better known, and more powerful San Diego convention.

Brennan already has a successful track record under his belt in defending these types of cases. He is perhaps best known for successfully defending the Novell corporation in retaining its ownership of the UNIX operating system name in 2012. Those who are watching the case, especially fans of the Salt Lake City convention, hope that a win for Salt Lake will set a legal precedent that will even the playing field for it and other comic book conventions across the country.

If the court sides with the much newer and smaller Salt Lake convention over the older and more recognized San Diego convention, San Diego's power in the convention world will be limited to its own event. It will not have any type of power over other, similar conventions. This is exactly what the fans of Salt Lake and other small conventions want. A win for Salt Lake is a win for smaller conventions everywhere in the United States. With Brennan, they stand a good chance of getting it.

The lawsuit began on August 7, 2014, when San Diego Comic Con filed its initial complaint in the U.S. District Court in Southern California. In its complaint, San Diego is seeking an injunction against Salt Lake from calling itself the Salt Lake Comic Con, and is also seeking financial damages caused by Salt Lake's use of the name to date. The organizers of the San Diego Comic Con allege that the Utah convention has been reaping the benefits of the hard work and good name of the San Diego convention by infringing upon its trademark in using a too similar name.

The Salt Lake convention organizers have publicly said the lawsuit is without merit. Meanwhile, they are working with their attorney to draft an official response to San Diego's lawsuit which must be filed with the court by early September.

The organizers of the Salt Lake convention would like to resolve the dispute amicably. However, they are prepared to take it to court if necessary, and to fight it all the way to the highest court that will hear the case.

This goes to show how important it is to get good representation in business to business lawsuits. Salt Lake's choice of attorney may make all the difference for them. If your company is facing a business to business lawsuit, the Coulter Law Group can make all the difference for you, too.

Posted in:

Related Posts

Two men discuss legal matters across a table, with a scale of justice .

What Do I Do If I'm in a Business Dispute?

An internal or external business dispute can wreak havoc on individuals and companies alike. Fortunately, you have several legal options for coping with a dispute in the manner best suited to your particular challenge. Amicable Resolutions Buyout - One partner in a business can buy out another's ownership in a business when differences appear irreconcilable. As is the case with so many business decisions, the best time to deal with this contingency is before the need arises. Every business partnership should have their attorneys create a formal buy-sell agreement that covers the entire process in detail. HG Legal Sources notes that when one partner offers to buy the other partner out, the second partner may have the option to reverse the request and but the first partner out instead, a situation known as "I cut, you choose." Sale - Selling the business may allow everyone involved to exit the business and see some profit at the same time. On the other hand, this process can generate plenty of fresh new disputes over how the proftis from such a sale should be divided. Selling a business can be a lengthy, challenging process. Think carefully about how long you want the resolution of your business to take; you may find that a less remunerative but faster process is more to everyone's liking. Dissolution - Dissolving a business is a relatively fast and clean form of dispute resolution. As described by the U.S. Small Business Administration, the process generally takes just 90 days and involves the submission of a one-page form to the state. While the dissolving partners will need to make vendors, contractors, and partnering businesses aware of the dissolution, they are not held accountable for each other's debts or liabilities in regard to the business. Going to Court If your dispute cannot be resolved through amicable means, it's time to go to court. Legal battles require considerable legal expertise and experience. Lawyers.com points out, for instance, that he lawsuit must be brought in the appropriate court, for instance. The complainant must also ask for a specific judgment from the court, whether it involves a financial reward or an order to cease and desist from the offending behavior. Settlements - If the parties in the dispute would prefer to cut their courtroom expenses short or avoid going to judgment, a settlement behind closed doors can put an end to the court proceedings. The party bringing the lawsuit will agree to let the other party pay less damages, while the other party may concede to some, but not all, of the business changes originally requested. Judgments - If either you or the other party in the dispute refuse to settle out of court, there is no other option but to take the case all the way to judgment. In this scenario, you'll need all the legal expertise at your disposal to make your case while weakening the opposition's case. The judge will then pronounce a verdict or guilty or not guilty and award damages. All of these options will likely call for legal assistance at some point or other. You can get your partnership off to a strong start by seeking this assistance as early as possible, especially in the structuring of the business and the creation of agreements that enable smoother operation and better communications. Contact Coulter Law Group to learn more.

Two people reviewing finances with receipts and a calculator on a table.

Business or Personal? Issues Causing Businesses to Fail

In the course of doing business, it is inevitable that some businesses will fail. However, it is also incumbent on owners of small and medium businesses to study the causes of business failure in order to avoid them. Leaders in small- to medium-sized businesses are often the key factors in success. Therefore, it is also true that personal issues can lead to business failures. Business failures can often be avoided with conscientious study and proper analysis. Here is a list of common issues to watch for that lead to business failure unless corrected in time. Poor Calculations Sometimes no matter how hard we work, the supposition at the foundation of our business just does not pan out. This issue can occur when the competition is too large, unexpected circumstances change or products become obsolete. These types of problems can rarely be avoided unless the business can adapt in time. Owners that are the Problem Owners can be the problem in and of themselves. There are owners with personality defects that impede growth and success in a business. These issues can include inflated egos, poor communication skills, lack of confidence, lack of experience, avoidance of risk or even just plain stubbornness. If the owner cannot acknowledge and correct personal issues, the business may fail. Owners can ask third-party consultants to come in and assess their business to discover problems of this nature. Third-party consultants do not have an investment in the business, and can offer valuable insight without risking a job or partnership. Personnel Issues Besides the owners, other personnel are important to maintaining and growing a business. If those personal are experiencing personal issues such as depression, anger or divorce, they may not be able to give their full attention to their jobs. In small- to medium-sized businesses, personnel have a huge impact on the success of the business. Offering employees counseling or mental health days can help in these instances. Legal Issues It is unfortunate to know that sometimes businesses fail due to legal issues caused by employees or customers. Legal issues can drive a business into the ground if they are severe. If an employee is embezzling funds or committing fraud, the business can suffer a loss of reputation. Smaller ethics issues can also cause problems such as a lack of honesty when problems crop up or employees that are not willing to own up to mistakes. Other legal issues can occur when one or more employees are substance abusers or influenced by outside forces. It is crucial to offer proper training to company leadership to detect legal issues before they get too big. Poor Accounting Businesses cannot be run for long without proper accounting. It is too easy for funds to disappear or get misappropriated. Most small businesses need to budget carefully in order to keep cash flowing; therefore, poor accounting can cause a large problem in a short amount of time. Having accounting records reviewed by more than one person on a regular monthly or weekly basis can alleviate accounting problems. Lack of Cash As we have seen in the last several years, businesses are cyclical and so is the economy. All businesses need to carefully cultivate a cash cushion to help when times are tough. Financial advisors outside of the company structure can offer advice for accumulating cash resources. Overexpansion Overextending a business is one of the saddest reasons companies go under. When a business allows growth to happen too fast, it cannot always keep up with rising expenses. Business owners need to control business growth with an eye on problematic growing pains. Keeping an experienced financial advisor on retainer can help keep growth under control. Operational Issues Without proper guidance, inexperienced business owners may find themselves paying too much for rent, utilities or labor. Undefined roles and expectations can lead to important tasks slipping through the cracks. No business owner can be an expert in all parts of their business. They need to determine their own areas of expertise, and bring in experts to study how the business can become more efficient and profitable in other areas.

A person writing on paper at a desk, with a scale of justice, a gavel, and books.

Give Me 2 Hours and I'll Show You How to Start a Successful Business

It seems like every day there's some new salesman on television, promoting their system for getting rich quick. They tell you that anyone can start making serious money, as long as they follow their advice, learn their secrets, and pay them quite a bit of money in the process. Usually, these kind of schemes that promise wealth overnight are just scams and not something you want to get involved in. However, if you are interested in starting up your own business, there are definitely some things you should learn that can help your new business venture be successful. These are not secrets, just principles and guidelines, and it shouldn't cost you an arm and a leg to learn them. Here are some things to remember if you're trying to find help as you start your business. Get Help from a Professional First of all, make sure you get your business advice from a professional, and not just some guy you saw on the shopping network on television. A seasoned business professional would be a great person to learn from. Also, don't forget to talk to a business lawyer. Sure, you may have a brilliant business idea. However, unless you understand the ins and outs of business law, or at least have a lawyer on your side that does, you are bound to get overwhelmed by the legal side of starting a business. Take a Minute to Learn about the Law If you take the time to sit down with a business lawyer, he or she can walk you through the basics of laws pertaining to your new business and help you feel more comfortable as you begin your new venture. For example, if you are thinking of trying to sell this great product you've designed, there will be patents, forms, and many other legal documents you need to file before you can start selling the product. On the other hand, if you're starting up a restaurant, it will be really beneficial to gain a basic understanding of your state's health code, hiring practices, and other laws pertaining to the food industry. Just a little bit of time learning about the law before you dive in to your new business can really pay off in the end. Plan, Plan, Plan There are some times in life when it can be fun to be spontaneous, to wake up one morning and decide that today is the day you do that crazy thing you've always dreamed of doing. Starting a business is not one of those times. If you are thinking of starting a new business, you must take the time to plan. What do you need to plan? You will need to figure out your financial backing, how you are going to make a profit, how long it will take before your business brings in a profit, what your short and long term goals are, your marketing strategy, and more. Taking the time to plan this all out and get any professional advice you might need will contribute to the success of your business. Try to be patient and give yourself the necessary time to sort things out before you dive in to your exciting new venture.